A comment was made last week by one of the people in the pub that when taking communion the week before, he felt they’d just kind of “rushed it” and didn’t take it very seriously. Little was said, it was just kind of “something to do during one of the songs.” Do modern churches water down the true Gospel to make it as inoffensive as possible? Is “Gospel-lite” that is actually heard better than “Gospel Supreme” which weirds people out?
So therein lies our discussion for this week. Let us weigh in the two extremes and perform a little cost/benefit analysis. In one corner, we have a church which is very modern. They have modern sounding music. You can come dressed however you wish–you may not even be sitting in a “pew” but a chair or even around a table of some sort. It’s very comfortable and non-confrontational–totally not what your non-christian friends think church is like.
In the other corner lies a church where they use antiquated terms “thee” and “thou” and call other believers “brethren” (creepy, right?). In this church, they sing hymns written usually 100-200 years ago in a style far removed from anything one would find on the average person’s iPod playlist. The tone of the service is very traditional and challenging to follow.
On one hand, I find myself quite uncomfortable sitting a service that is being played out like some folks’ idea of how church was done 100 years ago. I mean, isn’t God living and active in this world? Why are they clinging to lost ways? But on the other hand, the reverence with which they approach God inspires and humbles me.
In a more “comfortable” church, the message can potentially be stated in a manner more clearly understood by a contemporary audience (didn’t Jesus speak in what was then considered contemporary terms, after all? Can anyone say parable?). However, is this sometimes carried so far as to make people place their lives first and their faith second? They only come because it’s comfortable and it “fits”?
I see merit and fault in both approaches. I will leave you with two videos which I feel poke fun at both extremes. See you Tuesday 17th at 7pm!